:quality(70)/cloudfront-eu-central-1.images.arcpublishing.com/irishtimes/H24F2IPOKA2KVG5R5U37PBUZTI.jpg)
A man who sent sexually explicit videos to a Fine Gael TD during the 2020 general election campaign has been handed a suspended sentence and ordered to stay away from Leinster House.
Gerard Culhane (43) of Marian Place, Glin, Co Limerick, pleaded guilty at Dublin Circuit Criminal Court to harassing Jennifer Carroll MacNeill at unknown places within the State on dates between January 13th, 2020 and March 26th, 2020. He has no previous convictions.
Imposing sentence on Friday, Judge Patricia Ryan said the period in question had been “very disturbing and frightening” for the TD, particularly as it occurred during a general election campaign when she was meeting people.
Judge Ryan imposed a one-year custodial sentence suspended for 12 months on strict conditions.
:quality(70)/cloudfront-eu-central-1.images.arcpublishing.com/irishtimes/ZU666T7JRRALPLRUHRHHE6G54Y.jpg)
:quality(70)/cloudfront-eu-central-1.images.arcpublishing.com/irishtimes/WPH4BAM4SHQFVLTYX24GORCKRU.jpg)
:quality(70)/cloudfront-eu-central-1.images.arcpublishing.com/irishtimes/5JC53HMTSZHTNCZBZSY65ZLEH4.jpg)
:quality(70)/cloudfront-eu-central-1.images.arcpublishing.com/irishtimes/6VTKTFZQW5NEA3LSIGO5FDKWDI.jpg)
She ordered Culhane to have no contact with the TD in person, by social media or via a third party for a period of five years.
Judge Ryan also directed Culhane to stay away from Ms Carroll MacNeill’s place of work at Leinster House, her constituency offices and her residence.
The court previously heard that Culhane sent the TD 13 messages over the period in question, including three sexually explicit videos, which he later admitted to gardaí he had downloaded from a pornographic website.
Judge Ryan said the aggravating factors in this case included the amount of messages sent and the effect the harassment had on the TD during an “important”, “busy and stressful part of her life”.
As a result, the TD had safety concerns, particularly as she was meeting with members of the public during an election campaign.
It would have been a “distressing and frightening” experience for the TD to not know the identity of the person harassing her “when she was meeting people on a daily basis,” Judge Ryan said.
Setting the headline sentence at two years, Judge Ryan noted Culhane appeared at the time to be very socially isolated and dealing with a medical issue at the time of the offending.
Judge Ryan noted the mitigating factors include the guilty plea, the lack of previous convictions, and Culhane’s co-operation with gardai.
Taking the mitigating factors into account, Judge Ryan imposed a one-year prison sentence, which she suspended for 12 months on strict conditions.
Defence counsel Karl Monahan BL said the probation report indicates that his client is at low risk of re-offending.
His client also told the probation officer that he wished to apologise to the TD and was remorseful for his actions.
“In hindsight, if he could change the decision he made, he would”, Mr Monahan said, adding that his client deeply regrets the effect of his actions on the TD, her family and his own family.
Defence counsel also handed in a testimonial from a member of a sports club on behalf of Culhane.
Mr Monahan also confirmed that Culhane had made a donation to Aoibhneas Womens Refuge in Coolock, Dublin, a charity nominated by Ms Carroll MacNeill.
Victim impact statement
In her victim impact statement, Ms Carroll MacNeill previously told the court that she had been in middle of a general election at the time and the harassment from Culhane was “extremely difficult to deal with”.
“I do not wish to be here,” the Deputy said, before she added that “with every fibre of my being” she didn’t wish to waste the time of the court, the gardaí or the Director of Public Prosecutions. But because Culhane sent her “unsolicited images... we all have to be here”, she said.
She said she would rather spend her time more constructively working in the Oireachtas, serving her constituents and spending time with her young son.
“But because some man thought it was OK to invade my life and my mind and my sense of security because of whatever twisted purpose he got out of it, I have to use my time to pursue it,” she said.
“I do not choose to be sexualised in this way, to be in media articles with sexual content. But because some man decided to send me sexually explicit videos, it is there for ever more for everyone to see. All of this is without my consent,” Ms Carroll MacNeill said.
She said didn’t wish to be “a victim”. “I am a private person and I just don’t like it,” the TD said, before adding she was “keen to downplay” the case.
Ms Carroll MacNeill said at the time, she was worried for her safety because she was in the middle of a general election during which time the main objective is to go out and meet as many members of the general public as possible.
She said she got an awful fright when she received the messages and she didn’t want to worry about her safety at the time. “We all needed to get on with the job”, she said.
Ms Carroll MacNeill said she was on high alert and her team and close family were more protective of her.
“No one should have to get unsolicited sexual content. It greatly impacted me in the process of trying to become an elected representative,” she continued.
“When you are running an election, the key objective is to physically meet people. I was afraid for the first time.”
She said there “a real actual risk” to her. “I felt it, and I couldn’t see it.”
She felt didn’t know where the threat was, or what the nature of it was. “Was the person far away from me, crossing the road towards me. What were they going to do? Was I going to be attacked?”
She said at the time she had “a cold sense of dread” and spoke of a reluctance to smile, to put out her hand and engage.
“But in my mind, whether rationally or not, this person, whoever they were, now had every opportunity to simply walk up and see me up close and be near me. And this terrified me.
I just didn’t know where it would go and I thought, I’m not putting up with this,” the TD continued.
She said the impact of Culhane sending her these messages had a wider effect on her family, her husband, parents and sister and said “something of this nature” can just “creep into your life” while out walking with her husband and her dogs, having coffee with her mother or sitting watching television with her son.