Courts

Crossmaglen man jailed for three years for brutal and premeditated assault

Eugene Hanratty Snr (63) punched victim’s head, kicked him on the ground and stamped on his arm

File photograph of Eugene Hanratty. Photograph: Collins Courts

Sonya McLean
Tue Nov 8 2022 - 14:24

A farmer has been jailed for three years for a brutal and “premeditated” assault on his neighbour in Monaghan 10 years ago.

Eugene Hanratty Snr (63) of Castleblayney Road, Crossmaglen, Armagh was convicted by a jury following a trial last month. He had pleaded not guilty to assault causing harm at Castleblayney, Co Monaghan on November 24th, 2012.

Detective Garda Paul Everard told Garrett McCormack BL, prosecuting, that on the Saturday afternoon of the attack, Martin McAllister and his wife were driving at 4.20pm in Castleblayney on their way to Crossmaglen when a vehicle approached with its full headlights on.

Mr McAllister told the trial that he felt his path was blocked by the other vehicle and he couldn’t drive past it. He then recognised the occupants of the car as being father and son, Eugene Hanratty Snr and his son Eugene Jnr.

READ MORE

The defendant got out of his car and began an assault on Mr McAllister in his vehicle, the trial heard. The victim said that Hanratty punched him a number of times in the head, pulled him down by the hair and kicked him before the defendant dragged him out of the vehicle.

Mr McAlister told the trial that the assault continued outside the car, with Hanratty continually kicking him while he was on the ground. His right arm was stamped on and he went in and out of consciousness.

He testified that Hanratty Snr was aware he was a musician so he felt the stamping on his arm was significant in this regard.

Victim Martin McAllister, leaving Dublin Circuit Criminal Court on Tuesday after Eugene Hanratty Snr was sentenced to three years in prison for his assault. Photograph: Collins Courts

Det Gda Everard said that the victim’s wife Mary McAllister told the jury that it was a sustained attack while her husband was both inside the car and out of the car.

She described asking Hanratty Snr to stop because she was concerned if the assault continued the injuries would be fatal for her husband. The trial heard that Hanratty Jnr also asked his father to stop attacking the man.

The victim suffered multiple broken bones in his face, both his eye sockets were broken and he has been left with a permanent loss of his peripheral vision. He has been treated numerous times but without success and the loss of his peripheral vision “impinges on my everyday life”.

Sentencing on Tuesday, Judge Melanie Greally said that the jury rejected Hanratty’s defence of justified use of force which maintained that the violence arose as a result of a physical altercation following a dispute in relation to duck shooting rights on local lands.

She said the court was sentencing Hanratty on the basis of no information of any long-standing history between the parties and treating the assault as unprovoked and pre-meditated.

She said the aggravating factors included this clear pre-meditation, the severity and brutality of the violence, the fact that most of the blows, including kicks, were directed at the victim’s head and face and the fact that Hanratty stamped on the victim’s arm knowing the victim is a musician.

She said she also took into consideration the adverse effects of the assault on the quality of life of the victim and his family and the fact that the assault was carried out in front of the man’s wife.

She set a headline sentence of five years, which is the maximum penalty for the offence.

Judge Greally then noted as mitigating factors Hanratty’s lack of any recent convictions and the fact that this type of “extreme violence” was entirely out of character. She noted his otherwise good character and his positive contributions to his family and his community and said he was a hard working “hands on” farmer.

Padraig Dwyer SC, defending, had earlier submitted that his client was “a pillar of the community” who contributed to local community activities including the church and the GAA. He said while his client does not accept fully the jury verdict, he does accept he did act and used excessive violence on the day.

Judge Greally said there was no tangible expressions of remorse from the defendant, “not even a suggestion of an apology for the injuries he has caused”. But she said she accepted that his imprisonment would have a severe impact on his family and would be a source of shame and humiliation for him and his family.

She also noted that a prison sentence for someone of his age and standing is particularly difficult and noted his mental health difficulties as set out in a psychological report.

Taking all these mitigating factors into consideration, she set a sentence of four years and suspended the final year on condition that he have no contact with Mr McAllister or his family for the next decade.

The conviction last month came after the third trial in the case. The first trial resulted in a disagreement and the jury couldn’t reach a verdict, the second trial collapsed after the jury was discharged. Last October the jury unanimously convicted Hanratty Snr following one-hour deliberations.

Hanratty Snr has two previous convictions; one for assault of a garda in 1989 and one for criminal damage in 1997, the court heard. He has not come to garda attention since the 2012 assault.

In October 2016 another jury at Dublin Circuit Criminal Court acquitted Eugene Hanratty Junior (41) Dundalk Road, Crossmaglen, Armagh of assaulting Mr McAllister causing him harm. It was the State’s case that he had not taken part in the physical beating but he was charged on the basis of joint enterprise.

Devastating effect

Mr McAllister said that the “pre-meditated” and vicious assault had a devastating effect on his life both physically and mentally. He said medical reports before the court “substantiated” the physical injuries.

He said he had multiple broken bones in his face, both his eye sockets were broken and he has been left with a permanent loss of his peripheral vision. He has been treated numerous times but without success and the loss of his peripheral vision “impinges on my everyday life”.

Mr McAllister, said that as a musician, he struggles now to read musical notation.

He said the nerves in his face were also damaged by the injuries to his eyes and he has been left with excruciating pain to the left side of his face. He underwent surgical nerve decompression in 2014 and had a titanium implant fitted below his left eye which altered his sensation down the left side of his face.

Mr McAllister said this has left him with constant issues while eating and drinking. He also described problems with his sinuses as a result and said he continues to have problems with injuries he received to his right arm.

“I have had 10 years of these problems which will continue for the rest of my life,” Mr McAllister said.

“It has been a ten-year long wait for justice which has taken a toll on my mental wellbeing. I have lost confidence and I struggle every day to keep myself going,” Mr McAllister said before he added that he has been prescribed both short and long-term medication to help with anxiety.

“There is no escape from this torture,” he continued.

Referring to the fact that his wife witnessed the assault, Mr McAllister said she has since been diagnosed with suffering from Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder, anxiety and depression. “Her suffering fills me with sadness,” Mr McAllister said.

He concluded his victim impact statement by taking the opportunity to thank the court and the justice system who accompanied him “on this long walk to justice”.

LATEST STORIES